Mass video surveillance (also known as close-circuit television, or CCTV) is the large-scale collection, storage and analysis of video and audio data from video surveillance cameras. Mass video surveillance aims to capture the identity of people who pass through a space and to extend its coverage to as much space as possible. Some countries now have more surveillance cameras than citizens.
Sources of CCTV footage include:
- Cameras in the street or in other public locations.
- Cameras in private buildings (e.g. shops, offices).
- Public transport cameras on buses, trains, highways, etc.
- Home surveillance systems such as Amazon Ring.
- In-vehicle surveillance systems like those found on Teslas.
CCTV cameras can vary widely in quality, range, night vision capabilities, presence of microphones, etc.
After its collection, CCTV footage is often stored for some time (from days to indefinite durations) before being erased.
An adversary can analyze CCTV footage:
- In real time if the cameras are integrated into a central network. Real-time analysis can take place either as part of routine surveillance or during exceptional events (e.g. demonstrations).
- Retroactively if the CCTV footage has been stored. Retroactive analysis can help identify a suspect by their face, gait, voice, etc.
Analysis of CCTV footage can be performed:
- By humans.
- By automated systems such as automated license plate readers or facial recognition systems.
- You Can't Catch What You Can't See: Against Video Surveillance.
- The topics “Video surveillance” and “Automated license plate readers”.
Used in tactics: Deterrence, Incrimination
Mitigations
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Anonymous dress | You can dress anonymously to prevent an adversary from identifying you from CCTV footage. |
| Anonymous purchases | You can make anonymous purchases to prevent an adversary from identifying you from CCTV footage of physical stores. |
| Attack | You can disable surveillance cameras. |
| Biometric concealment | When filmed by surveillance cameras, you can:
|
| Outdoor and device-free conversations | You can conduct sensitive conversations away from surveillance cameras to prevent an adversary from recording those conversations with surveillance cameras equipped with microphones. |
| Reconnaissance | Before an action, you can identify the location of surveillance cameras at an action site and make plans to avoid them if possible. |
| Transportation by bike | You can use a bike instead of any other type of vehicle: compared to other vehicles, a bike is much harder to identify on CCTV footage, especially if its distinguishing features are minimized. For example, you can use a different stolen bike for each action you carry out. |
Used in repressive operations
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Case against Peppy and Krystal | CCTV footage from a bus allowed investigators to identify the license plate of the motorcycle on which Peppy and Krystal arrived at and left the protest site[1]. |
| Repression of Lafarge factory sabotage | Immediately after the action, investigators requested CCTV footage from public transportation (buses, train stations, etc.), businesses, home surveillance systems, and municipal cameras, all within an extended perimeter of the action site[2]. In particular, footage of the interiors of buses appears to have helped identify people traveling to and from the action site[3]. Investigators also requested footage from highway toll booths, presumably to identify the occupants of known cars traveling on highways to or from the action site. |
| Repression of the first Jane's Revenge arson | CCTV footage helped identify a vehicle driven by the person, when they were seen entering a parking lot on foot after a demonstration, and the vehicle was seen leaving the same parking lot a few minutes later[4]. |
| Case against Boris | Soon after the April sabotage, investigators requested CCTV footage from businesses and municipal cameras, and lists of vehicles from automated license plate readers (ALPRs) and speed cameras, all within an extended perimeter of the sabotage site[5]. |
| 2019-2020 case against Mónica and Francisco | Public CCTV footage was extensively used by investigators to reconstruct the movements of Mónica and Francisco before and during the actions, despite the mitigations they took (taking taxis, changing clothes, wearing disguises)[6]. |
| The three from the park bench | On the evening leading up to the arrest, one of the people — while being followed by cops — stopped at a gas station and was seen by the station's video surveillance cameras buying gas and filling a gas can[7]. The cops obtained the CCTV footage the next morning. |
| Bure criminal association case | Investigators used footage from the demonstrations, recorded by surveillance cameras and police forces, to[8]:
|
| Prometeo | Two of the people were allegedly seen on video surveillance leaving a store where investigators believe the envelopes used to prepare the parcel bombs were purchased[9]. |
| 2013 case against Mónica and Francisco | Public CCTV footage was used by investigators to reconstruct the movements of Mónica and Francisco before and after the action[10]. This showed that they were near the action site shortly before the explosion of the device. |
Private source.